Angela's full Grouse shooting debate speech

Resize text

My speech for the Grouse shooting debate, or rather the one I would have given if I’d had the time!  

BB-hharrier-8 Moors in my area characterized by a long tradition of grouse shooting; but nevertheless they represent a habitat which is badly degraded and which needs a lot attention if it is to be restored to

 

Favourable Condition StatusOne still able to enjoy the wonders of nature – curlew, snipe, the golden plover and the fantastic mountain hare.  But no peregrine and no hen harriers; peregrines nesting happily in Sheffield city centre but not on the moors in my constituency.

 

The petition, two petitions in fact.

 

Huge concern over the plight of the hen harrier and other raptors and quite rightly so; in 2013, there were no successful hen harrier nests in England and the numbers remain stubbornly and pitifully lowOf course this debate is also concerned with the conservation status of the moorland habitat favoured for grouse production and shooting 

 

Lot of confusion over this habitat; grouse moors in my area, for instance, are areas of blanket bog which support extensive heather habitat; this is quite typical of grouse moors more generally, and it is important to understand the need to balance conservation of a healthy heather habitat with the need to restore and maintain our precious blanket bog.

 

Need to be clear at this point; causes of blanket bog degradation are varied. Industrial and atmospheric pollution, over grazing, wind erosion, drainage of the moorland.  The management of moorland for grouse is one of many factors, in fact, and it is important to be honest about the full extent of the reasons why moorland in areas like mine are in such a sorry state – not least, of course, because we need to tackle tough issues such as atmospheric pollution and climate change 

 

But the management of moorland habitat for grouse has become controversial, not least because increasingly the feeling is that there has been a significant prioritization of habitat conducive to maximum grouse production, at the expensive of the health of our blanket bog

 

And of course the burning regimes traditionally favoured as a moorland management tool are at the heart of this particular controversy

 

What doesn’t help is that the science is genuinely unclear on this.  

 

Much work is being carried out; references were made in the evidence session last week to the various studies already undertaken in relation to burning on blanket bog and its hydrological and various other impacts, for instance, on temperature and biodiversity 

 

But more work needs to be done and I am pleased that the University of York has undertaken a 10 year, longitudinal study which attempts to remove as many variables as possible from its experiments, especially in relation to pre-management regimes, in order to establish a more robust understanding of the impacts of current management standards on blanket bog moorland

 

This study is 5 years through and has been funded by DEFRA.  It needs a further fiveyears if we are to secure a set of robust conclusions.  DEFRA is not committing to Phase 2, however, apparently because of cuts, and this despite the fact that at the very most, an extra £650k is required. 

 

I look forward to the Minister’s comment on this in her conclusions and to a commitment that this project will continue.  

 

I acknowledge, however, that we cannot wait for the science to make progress.  Just 26,000 of our 176,000 hectares of upland blanket bog classified as SSIs are in favourable condition.

of course, when it come to our wonderful birds of prey, let’s remember that we saw only three successful hen harrier nests this year in England

 

We just can’t wait; we need to resolve the conflict on our grouse moors now and we need to make every effort to establish management regimes that balance economic and conservation interests, regimes which are capable of adjusting to change as new science emerges to establish best practice 

 

Now, there are a number of options available to us as the science around grouse moor management evolves

 

The first involves the voluntary approach, favoured by DEFRA.  Its Strategy for the Restoration of Blanket Bog was published last year and focused in its overarching vision on not only ‘restoring or enhancing the range of ecosystem benefits relevant for each site’, but also on ‘building and supporting sustainable businesses in the uplands which have adapted to work in harmony with the requirements of well-functioning blanket bog 

Now that’s all worthy, and implicit in this vision is, of course, the restoration of a healthy population of raptors on our grouse moors

 

But if this Strategy is to work, the Minister must show some leadership and demonstrate a sense of her responsibility to do all she can to make this work.  

So, I have a number of questions for the Minister: 

 

The Strategy details the need for a working definition, at England level, of what Favourable Condition Status is in relation to blanket bog.  Can we have a progress report, please, from the Minister, as this definition is critical to the development of the Site Restoration Plans that will underpin the implementation of the strategy.  And can she confirm that this definition will include measures relating to raptor populations?

 

Year 1 of the  programme was dedicated to a series of ‘Bogathon’ events, accompanied by ‘active engagement on a suite of sites where positive relationships already exist or are developing and/or there is a significant opportunity to improve the condition of a site in the short term.’  The document goes on to point out that ‘these pilots will be important in demonstrating the benefits on the ground and also in refining the approach and potentially revealing further evidence needs.’

 

Again, can the Minister indicate that these Year 1 milestones have been successfully concluded? And will she commit to updating the House in writing as to the lessons learned from this first phase? 

 

This matters, because of course if the House is to be satisfied that the voluntary approach to resolving issues relating to our grouse moors is going to work, we have to hear from the Minister that the Government’s own strategy in this regard is on track to deliver positive outcomes.

 

And of course confidence matters, because the debate about how best to manage our grouse moors is increasingly contentious, increasingly fraught. 

 

Even those of us who believe in the voluntary approach are beginning to despair.  The breeding of the hen harrier this year has been very poor in England, as I have already mentioned, and it is becoming clear that progress in delivering a sustainable future for our moorlands, which allows us to balance economic and environmental objectives, will stall, stutter and shudder to a halt unless something is done to stop the persecution of our birds of prey.

 

To put it quite simply, the killing must stop.  It must stop and it is quite clear now that this is a prerequisite to progress.  Even in the Peak District, where voluntary partnership working on raptors has been ongoing for some time, patience is wearing very thin indeed.  

 

Will the Minister therefore underpin the voluntary approach outlined in her department’s strategy for blanket bog restoration by exploring the possibility ofintroducing an offence of vicarious liability?  

 

Responsible landowners have nothing to fear from this and everything to gain; by isolating and effectively dealing with the illegalpractice, the law abiding majority can gain credibility and trust on all sides in this matter.  Indeed, will the Minister not acknowledge that the Hen Harrier Action Plan itself could be strengthened by such a move  

 

This brings me to licensing.  There are many regulations pertaining to grouse moor management, mentioned by the Hon Member for, and I accept that it is unclear how a licensing system would work to effectively streamline such regulations while also delivering a more sustainable system of moorland management.  

 

But will the Minister at least confirm that it has to stay on the table as a political option?  After all, if the implementation of the blanket bog strategy is fundamentally built on voluntary partnerships, then is it not equally true that legislative options need to be held in reserve?  

 

In other words, will the Minister spell out today how she will respond if it becomes apparent that the Strategy is failing to deliver? And if she does not think licensing would work in that context, when all else has failed, how will she proceed to take this essential work forward? What tools does she have in her box to restore blanket bog and raptor populations, in the event of the failure of the Strategy?

 

Two final points, Mr(s) 

 

First of all, it would aid the effort to build trust between different interests in this debate if the landowners were to commit themselves to more transparency in relation to their land ownership, and in relation to their receipt of public monies via agri environment schemes.  

 

So, will the Minister commit to at least looking at this?  I say this because there is unfortunately a lingering suspicion that the ownership and management of grouse moors is deliberately secretive and that there is something to hide.  Let’s shine a light on this; I don’t think for a minute that landowners have anything to lose from the introduction ofsuch a measure.

 

Secondly, the concept of banning grouse shooting.  This I do not support, first and foremost because I do not believe it would work.  It is an option, of course, but there is no evidence that banning grouse shooting would automatically deliver the end of persecution of birds of prey.  

 

This issue must be resolved, and it must be resolved soon.  It is a polarized debate, characterized by division and a lack of trust on all sides.  The Minister has a key role to play in dealing with this; at the very least, she has the power to send out a powerful, positive message about the future of our raptor populations and their relationship with our precious upland habitats.

 

So I look forward to hearing that message from her today and to hearing her answers to all my questions.  No more prevarication, let’s have leadership from the Minister and a clear sense of determination that the hen harrier and our grouse moors can look forward to better days.

 

Your neighbourhood

Penistone & Stocksbridge WardsDodworth West Ecclesfield East Ecclesfield Penistone East Penistone West Stocksbridge dodworth ward penistone east pen west stocks east eccles west eccles

Latest from Angela

Angela responds to the sale of Speciality Steels to Liberty House Grou...
Sunday, 12 February 2017
Angela Smith MP, whose constituency covers TATA... Read More...
Concerns over the future of Birch Avenue Nursing Home
Friday, 13 January 2017
Angela has today written to the Sheffield Clinical Care... Read More...
IMAGE Winners of Angela's Xmas Card Competition
Friday, 09 December 2016
Local school children collect prizes in local MPs Christmas... Read More...
IMAGE Angela's speech to the Opposition motion 3rd Dec 2016
Friday, 09 December 2016
Let me be absolutely clear. We cannot say this often... Read More...
IMAGE Angela calls for rural businesses in Yorkshire to be integral part of ...
Friday, 09 December 2016
Angela has backed calls made by the CLA (Country Land &... Read More...
IMAGE Angela responds to the sale of Speciality Steels to Liberty House Grou...
Monday, 28 November 2016
Angela, whose constituency covers TATA Stocksbridge has... Read More...
IMAGE Angela getting ready to campaign for our NHS
Friday, 25 November 2016
Angela finds it terrible that when the NHS is facing the... Read More...
IMAGE Angela becomes a species champion for the Hen Harrier
Tuesday, 15 November 2016
Angela has recently joined forces with a group of... Read More...
IMAGE Protecting Sheffield, Flooding Consultation response
Tuesday, 01 November 2016
Protecting Sheffield, Flooding... Read More...
Sheffield Councils Flood Plan needs more ambition
Tuesday, 01 November 2016
Angela Smith MP, a former Shadow Water Minister and whose... Read More...
IMAGE Angela's full Grouse shooting debate speech
Monday, 31 October 2016
My speech for the Grouse shooting debate, or rather the one... Read More...
IMAGE MPs stand out in pink for families affected by breast cancer
Tuesday, 11 October 2016
Angela recently showed her support for women affected by... Read More...
Angela asks constituents to consider helping little Harrison in his ho...
Monday, 10 October 2016
Local couple Paul and Hayley Allen from Penistone... Read More...
Angela's speech to the for Women@TUOSnet AGM Lunch
Thursday, 06 October 2016
Introduction I want to start my talk today by paying... Read More...
Angela calls for urgent action on energy bills
Wednesday, 05 October 2016
Hard-working families in Penistone & Stocksbridge could... Read More...
IMAGE Angela’s keynote address to the Raptors and Grouse Moors Conference
Monday, 19 September 2016
Can I first pay tribute to Ian and Christine for their... Read More...
IMAGE Don’t stop at 999: Angela attends British Red Cross event
Friday, 09 September 2016
MPs from across the UK recently attended a British Red... Read More...
IMAGE Sheffield Council Flood Prevention consultation
Tuesday, 30 August 2016
  In 2007 the city and in particular North West... Read More...
Angela speaks out on Barnsley Local Plan
Friday, 29 July 2016
Penistone and Stocksbridge MP Angela Smith has today... Read More...
IMAGE Angela pushes for public transport in Penistone
Friday, 29 July 2016
Local Labour Member of Parliament for Penistone and... Read More...
IMAGE Angela Backs British Farming
Tuesday, 19 July 2016
Angela recently attended a reception in Westminster... Read More...
Plant free trees with help from the Woodland Trust
Tuesday, 05 July 2016
Schools across north Sheffield and west Barnsley are being... Read More...
IMAGE Minister confirms South Yorkshire link to HS3
Friday, 15 April 2016
The Transport Minister, Andrew Jones has confirmed to... Read More...
IMAGE Study into the Pennine Tunnel welcomed
Tuesday, 15 March 2016
Study into the Pennine Tunnel welcomed but warm words are... Read More...
Angela's Speech to the Progress conference 13th March 2016
Monday, 14 March 2016
First of all, thank you to Progress for asking me to make a... Read More...
IMAGE Angela supports Alzheimer’s Society
Tuesday, 23 February 2016
 Earlier this month Angela Smith joined over 160 other... Read More...
IMAGE Angela joins World Animal Protection to save the National Wildlife Cri...
Thursday, 07 January 2016
Angela Smith this week offered her support World Animal... Read More...
IMAGE Angela helps raise the awareness of Puppy smuggling
Tuesday, 15 December 2015
Last week the Dogs Trust, the UK’s largest dog welfare... Read More...
IMAGE Angela's Christmas card winners 2015
Saturday, 05 December 2015
For a selection of photos of the prize giving... Read More...
IMAGE Angela supports launch of leading hearing loss report
Monday, 30 November 2015
Angela recently attended the Westminster launch of Hearing... Read More...
Angela marks World Toilet Day
Monday, 30 November 2015
Angela Smith, has joined calls on the UK Government to... Read More...
IMAGE Angela backs call for 50 year forward view for NHS
Wednesday, 25 November 2015
Angela has backed a call for the NHS to put in place... Read More...
IMAGE Ofcom launch online Mobile Coverage Checker
Tuesday, 24 November 2015
In August Ofcom launched an online Mobile Coverage Checker... Read More...
IMAGE Action is needed to regulate online sales of exotic pets
Tuesday, 24 November 2015
Angela Smith, MP for Penistone & Stocksbridge today... Read More...
IMAGE New Constituency Oiffce
Tuesday, 24 November 2015
Angela recently re-located her constituency to new premises... Read More...
IMAGE Angela lends her support to Pancreatic Cancer UK
Tuesday, 24 November 2015
Angela recently attended a cross-party event at the House... Read More...
IMAGE Angela Smith MP Hooks-a-Truck to clean up problem pavement parking
Tuesday, 27 October 2015
Angela Smith MP recently took on the challenge of cleaning... Read More...
IMAGE Politics goes pink for breast cancer awareness
Wednesday, 16 September 2015
Angela, has shown her support for women with breast cancer... Read More...
IMAGE Angela gives her support to calls for an end to Japan’s Antarctic wh...
Friday, 19 June 2015
 As Shadow Animal Welfare Minister, Angela has shown... Read More...
IMAGE Xmas Card winners
Tuesday, 09 December 2014
 On Saturday Angela presented awards to the winners of... Read More...
IMAGE Angela adds her support to to protect shopworkers from threats and abu...
Wednesday, 19 November 2014
Angela Smith MP has joined with members of the retail... Read More...
IMAGE Angela shows support for secondary breast cancer
Friday, 17 October 2014
Recently Breast Cancer Care met with Angela at Parliament,... Read More...
IMAGE End to “game of chance”
Thursday, 09 October 2014
Angela calls for an end to “game of chance” bus service... Read More...
Concerns raised over the viability of the site of the proposed Chapelt...
Thursday, 24 July 2014
Serious concerns have been brought to the attention... Read More...
IMAGE Angela highlights link between obesity and arthritis but offers optimi...
Monday, 14 July 2014
Angela has called for a greater focus on the links between... Read More...
IMAGE Angela congratulates local winner at BTEC awards
Monday, 14 July 2014
Penistone & Stocksbridge MP, Angela Smith recently had... Read More...
IMAGE Defra Shadow Minister Visits Dogs Trust Leeds
Monday, 14 July 2014
Angela recently visited the Leeds Dogs Trust rehoming... Read More...
IMAGE Angela visits Fox Valley in Stocksbridge
Wednesday, 18 June 2014
Angela visits Fox Valley site in Stocksbridge to see how... Read More...
IMAGE ANGELA OFFERS HER SUPPORT TO THE KENNEL CLUB’S MICROCHIPPING CAMPAIG...
Wednesday, 11 June 2014
With the launch of the Campaign to raise awareness of... Read More...
IMAGE Angela objects to the proposals to build motorway Services at Smithy W...
Wednesday, 14 May 2014
Angela has today (14th May 2104) objected to the proposed... Read More...
IMAGE surgery on a bus
Thursday, 01 May 2014
This Friday May 2nd Angela will be hosting her constituency... Read More...
Angela calls for a re-think on Chapeltown Academy
Thursday, 01 May 2014
In an Adjournment debate in the House of Commons (Wednesday... Read More...
New Job for Angela
Tuesday, 22 April 2014
After a mini reshuffle in the Shadow Ministerial teams... Read More...
IMAGE Angela lends her support to the International Diabetes Federation
Tuesday, 15 April 2014
Angela recently joined volunteers from the International... Read More...
Angela calls for more help for Energy Intensive Industries
Tuesday, 25 March 2014
Angela Smith MP well known supporter and campaigner for... Read More...
Barnsley MPs urge Government to put fairness at the heart of local gov...
Friday, 14 March 2014
Angela, along with the three other Barnsley MPs, Michael... Read More...
IMAGE Angela raises concerns over the transfer of trains from Trans Pennine ...
Wednesday, 12 March 2014
Angela recently held Ministers to account for their... Read More...
IMAGE Celebrating 9 years of the hunt ban Charities and MPs mark success of ...
Thursday, 13 February 2014
It is 20 years since the RSPCA, the League Against Cruel... Read More...
IMAGE Fox Valley gets the go ahead
Friday, 07 February 2014
Angela recently attended the signing of contracts... Read More...
Angela and David Blunket write to Gove over concerns about Chapeltown ...
Friday, 31 January 2014
Local MPs Angela Smith and David Blunkett have written to... Read More...
IMAGE Angela calls for the protection of Ancient Woodland from HS2 planned r...
Friday, 31 January 2014
Local MP, Angela Smith has today responded to the HS2 phase... Read More...
IMAGE MP Gets the chair treatment at new dentist’s surgery
Tuesday, 14 January 2014
Recently HDS Dental Care an NHS Dental Practice in... Read More...
Penistone MP calls for improvements to cross Pennine transport links
Monday, 06 January 2014
Figures show Woodhead Pass frequently closed due to bad... Read More...
IMAGE Angela sees hospital’s work to manage winter pressures
Tuesday, 17 December 2013
Angela recently visited Barnsley Hospital’s A&E... Read More...
IMAGE Paws for Thought
Thursday, 12 December 2013
Christmas to mark 35th anniversary of iconic dogs trust... Read More...
Penistone MP speaks out about energy costs for Intensive Energy manufa...
Wednesday, 04 December 2013
Angela Smith worries that high energy manufactures are... Read More...
Barnsley MPs call for reconsideration of new CCG funding formula
Wednesday, 04 December 2013
Three local MPs, Michael Dugher MP, Dan Jarvis MP and... Read More...
IMAGE Ozzie Owl gives a helping wing!
Sunday, 01 December 2013
Saturday 30th November saw Angela Smith MP and Sheffield... Read More...
IMAGE Angela offers her supports campaign to stamp out wildlife crime
Thursday, 28 November 2013
Angela has shown her commitment to protecting animals by... Read More...
Angela backs campaign to get local school children talking and learnin...
Thursday, 28 November 2013
Penistone and Stocksbridge schools urged to take part in... Read More...
Victory for Common Sense!!
Thursday, 28 November 2013
Angela was delighted to hear that an application to build... Read More...
IMAGE Angela joins Paralympians to show support for social care for disabled...
Tuesday, 29 October 2013
Local MP Angela Smith joined double Gold medallist... Read More...
Angela offers support to local residents against inappropriate develop...
Tuesday, 29 October 2013
After carefully considering an application to build more... Read More...
IMAGE Angela pushes giant button for autism
Friday, 18 October 2013
Angela has pushed a giant button as he pledged her support... Read More...
IMAGE Angela objects to the Siting of two wind turbines
Tuesday, 15 October 2013
Click here for full details of the letter After carefully... Read More...
IMAGE No meat for me, says Angela
Thursday, 03 October 2013
Angela is marking Mahatma Gandhi’s birthday by turning... Read More...
Angela welcomes improvements to Penistone Post Office
Friday, 27 September 2013
Angela has today welcomed plans by the Post Office to... Read More...
IMAGE Angela takes part in the big coffee morning
Friday, 27 September 2013
Local MP for Penistone and Stocksbridge, Angela Smith... Read More...
IMAGE Hero MP from Penistone joins the fight against breast cancer
Monday, 16 September 2013
Angela Smith MP for Penistone & Stocksbridge has joined... Read More...
Angela defends Charitable sector
Thursday, 12 September 2013
In a speach during the report stage of the lobbying and... Read More...
Angela backs fight on access to rare disease drugs
Friday, 06 September 2013
Angela has this week backed a major inquiry that warns... Read More...
The Government’s Lobbying Bill will hit local charity claims Angela
Tuesday, 03 September 2013
Angela Smith, MP for Penistone and Stocksbridge has... Read More...
Angela congratulates Wentworth Castle’s Victorian Conservatory
Tuesday, 30 July 2013
Angela has congratulated Wentworth Castle’s Victorian... Read More...
IMAGE Angela is named Parliamentarian of the Year 2013
Friday, 19 July 2013
Honorary Vice President of the League Against Cruel Sports,... Read More...
Angela Calls for better Broadband in Dodworth
Friday, 12 July 2013
Angela has today called for improvements to broadband... Read More...
Changes to the Probation Service
Monday, 01 July 2013
Government’s proposals will see up to 70% of probation... Read More...
No School Left Behind - speech by Stephen Twigg
Monday, 01 July 2013
Thank you to Matthew and the team at the RSA for hosting us... Read More...
MPs condemn scaremongering by UKIP representatives
Wednesday, 26 June 2013
Local MPs Angela Smith and David Blunkett, a former Home... Read More...
Angela re-acts to Oughtibridge factory closure
Friday, 24 May 2013
‘I am saddened by the news that the manufacturing... Read More...
Angela asks for Sheffield’s name to be protected
Friday, 24 May 2013
Government Red Tape Challenge to un-protect the... Read More...
IMAGE Stop Puppy farming
Thursday, 16 May 2013
Stop the Badger Cull sign the petition NOW!!... Read More...
IMAGE Analysis on the recent local elections
Thursday, 16 May 2013
It’s the economy, stupid ..... What Labour needs to learn... Read More...
IMAGE Bus services for young people
Friday, 19 April 2013
Westminster Hall Debate, Bus Services for the... Read More...
IMAGE Angela speaks out on the latest dog attack
Wednesday, 27 March 2013
The dog attack on Jade Anderson is shocking and my... Read More...
IMAGE Angela speaks out on cuts to leisure services
Thursday, 14 March 2013
Westminster Hall Debate, Olympics Legacy and local sports... Read More...
IMAGE Angela Smith calls on Japan to end its cruel commercial whaling
Wednesday, 20 February 2013
Penistone & Stocksbridge MP, Angela Smith has called on... Read More...
IMAGE Angela creates buzz about bee decline
Thursday, 31 January 2013
Angela recently joined a giant bumble bee and campaigners... Read More...
IMAGE Angela welcomes HS2 announcement
Tuesday, 29 January 2013
Angela Smith MP (Pensitone & Stocksbridge) welcomed... Read More...
IMAGE Angela Smith stands up to prejudice
Thursday, 24 January 2013
Angela stands up to prejudice by signing Holocaust Memorial... Read More...
can't open file